Magazine / Why Finding Love Has Become So Difficult for Young Americans

Why Finding Love Has Become So Difficult for Young Americans

Arts & Culture Book Bites Happiness

Below, Daniel Cox shares five key insights from his new book, Generation Uncoupled: America’s New Gender Divide and the Crisis of Human Connection.

Daniel is the director of the Survey Center on American Life at the American Enterprise Institute, where he studies American attitudes, relationships, and social trends. He has spent more than two decades researching public opinion and the changing dynamics of American society.

What’s the Big Idea?

America’s growing gender divide isn’t simply about men and women failing to understand each other. It reflects a culture that has made personal autonomy a priority while forgetting that relationships require us to put other people’s needs alongside our own.

Listen to the audio version of this Book Bite—read by Daniel himself—in the Next Big Idea App, or buy the book.

1. Wake up as the opposite sex.

In early 2026, I worked with the National Opinion Research Center at the University of Chicago to conduct a nationally representative survey of American teenagers. As part of this research, we asked each respondent to consider the following: “Imagine you wake up and you are now a teenager of the opposite sex. In a few sentences, write about your experience—what are you feeling, what are you excited about or worried about as you begin your day?” Their task was to write a short reply, and roughly eight in ten boys and girls made at least some attempt to do so.

The most consistent response, from both boys and girls, was that the experience would be disorienting. The word “weird” came up more than a few times. Girls were more aware of the advantages afforded to them by switching genders, while boys’ reactions were more negative. Boys provided less detailed responses, using significantly fewer words on average. And although the prompt specifically asked them to consider some aspect of the experience that would be exciting, not a single boy used that word in their response. Many girls did. But a depressing conclusion from this exercise was the demonstrable lack of genuine curiosity expressed by boys and girls alike about what it’s like to live as the opposite sex. Here’s a sample of what they said:

  • A fifteen-year-old boy said, “I would be very upset. I can’t imagine myself as a girl. They giggle too much.”
  • A fourteen-year-old girl said, “Eww! I’m gross and I’m sweaty and now I can’t wear any of my clothes, so I’ll have to wear my brother’s gross ones and now I can’t do any of my hobbies anymore because they’re feminine, but I guess I can wrestle people.”
  • A seventeen-year-old boy said, “I would attempt to see how easily I could manipulate the system. How much money I could make and how many people I could take advantage of.”

Boys and girls have always viewed things somewhat differently, but historically we’ve seen this gap recede as they each gain more life experience and spend time together. This generation of young adults is not following the same path.

2. Everyone is exceptional.

Modern parents are nothing if not boosters for their children. In a survey of parents, only one in ten rated their children below average in academic achievement—a statistical impossibility. Most parents believe their children are above average. And parents eager to advocate for their children have demonstrated a willingness to “snowplow” obstacles and institutional impediments, especially in education. It has become much more common for parents to intercede on their child’s behalf for poor performance on an exam. Or seek out special accommodations for their children. Atlantic reporter Rose Horowitch documented a growing trend toward students at elite colleges receiving special accommodations. 20 percent of undergraduates at Harvard University and Brown University are registered as disabled—and at some schools it can be as high as one in three.

The expectation has changed. Individuals no longer adapt to the institutions to which they belong, but rather pressure institutions to respond to individual needs and interests. In the process, students learn that they are unique and deserving of this type of consideration.

There is an unmistakable generational pattern here. Older Americans are far more likely than younger Americans to think that their parents believed they were ordinary or average. Most seniors—54 percent—said that when they were growing up, their parents believed they were entirely unremarkable children. This feeling became increasingly uncommon in subsequent generations. Only 36 percent of young adults today grew up believing their parents thought of them as average.

If every parent’s high esteem of their children were accurate, American society would resemble Garrison Keillor’s fictional town of Lake Wobegon, “where all the women are strong, all the men are good-looking, and all the children are above average.” But it’s not. Researchers have documented a link between parental overevaluation of children and the development of narcissism. Children acquire narcissistic beliefs such as “I am superior to others” or “I am entitled to privileges” when parents inflate their sense of themselves. These early experiences have led many young adults to believe the rules are negotiable, that there are always carve-outs or exceptions that can be made. As a result, they grow into adults who are less willing or able to make accommodations for the needs of others.

3. The class divide in dating.

Both single men and women can make strong arguments about whether dating is worse for their sex. In the world of online dating, single men can feel invisible or that their value as a partner comes more from what they are rather than who they are. Women can feel overwhelmed having to manage a barrage of incoming messages that can quickly turn aggressive or hostile. Overall, there are abundant examples of romantic disasters that support the claims on both sides.

But it’s not a competition, and in many cases the challenges are not comparable or even relatable. While single women tend to report a higher number of negative dating experiences, they are also going out on more dates, on average, than men. Many men could not afford to go out on multiple dates a week even if they had the opportunity.

“Both single men and women can make strong arguments about whether dating is worse for their sex.”

And if the purpose of dating is to form an exclusive relationship or even marriage, one group has far worse outcomes than almost everyone else. By this metric, young single men without college degrees are struggling the most in the modern dating market. 50 percent of young men ages 24 to 35 without a four-year degree are single, compared to only 31 percent of young men with college degrees. The education divide in dating is a chasm for young men. 28 percent of younger women without a college degree are single, a rate roughly similar to college-educated women, at 24 percent. Obviously, these statistics tell us nothing about the quality of romantic experiences or the stability of these relationships, but for men without degrees the struggle is more fundamental: It is about being chosen at all.

So why are so many men without degrees single? It’s not necessarily due to a lack of effort or interest. More than anything, studies consistently show that what seems to be damaging these men’s romantic prospects is their comparative lack of financial resources. For men, dating can be an expensive proposition. In one study of singles, roughly nine in ten men paid for the first date, and a majority paid for subsequent outings as well. Despite dramatic changes in the economic fortunes of men without college degrees, dating culture remains locked in another era.

It’s not only the size of the paycheck, but the source. Non-college men tend to work in more gender-segregated professions, such as construction or building trades, and thus have fewer opportunities to meet and socialize with women in the workplace. They are also far more likely to work in solitary occupations, whether that’s long-haul trucking or gig work, such as driving for Uber or DoorDash.

And compared to college graduates, men without degrees are less socially active by almost every conceivable measure—they report lower levels of membership in gyms, churches, book clubs, and intramural sports leagues. This is not entirely a question of financial resources either. These men are also found less often in places that have no financial barrier to entry, such as community centers, public parks, and libraries. These gaps reinforce social separation and reduce social and romantic opportunity. Everything becomes harder.

4. Friction is the point.

The modern world is designed to reduce friction. Good design is meant to make our interactions with the world seamless, requiring less physical or cognitive effort. Relying on DoorDash eases the burden of feeding ourselves, but we lose the opportunity to sharpen our cooking skills. Having GPS has allowed us to easily navigate without consulting maps or asking strangers for help, but we end up feeling less confident when driving around without it. There’s no doubt that these conveniences make our lives easier, but they diminish our sense of capability. We’re increasingly applying this same principle to the social world. A frictionless society becomes less patient, less tolerant of ambiguity, and less willing to deal with uncertainty. It’s been a disaster.

The problem with trying to make social interactions seamless is that they lose their value. The modern dating marketplace has become so much more seamless that social interactions are less memorable and less meaningful because they require little risk and even less effort. Because dating apps present a sea of strangers, singles are often less invested in romantic connections early on. Prioritizing frictionless interactions makes us more productive—we can swipe through more profiles, message more people, and go out on more dates—but the experience teaches us to value each interaction less.

“A frictionless society becomes less patient, less tolerant of ambiguity, and less willing to deal with uncertainty.”

Only 11 percent of single women, and 16 percent of single men, say they would go on a second date with someone they met online if the first date was subpar. That number jumps by over 30 points when it comes to someone introduced by a mutual acquaintance or close friend. In this scenario, close to half of singles report that they would be willing to give their date another shot. There are plenty of reasons people have mediocre dates: nervousness, lack of chemistry or interest, even simple miscommunication. Yet whatever the reason, your odds of having a second shot are far better if your date has some small connection to your social world.

Romantic success depends on social connection. Younger men with more close friends are less likely to be single, and the disparity is large. More than half—51 percent—of younger men who have no close friends report they are currently single. Only one in three younger men with at least six close friends are single. A rich social life is a precondition for romantic success.

5. We owe each other something.

Social media is awash in terrible relationship advice. In one recent post on X, a young woman shared her experience of breaking off a relationship with the boyfriend who wanted to marry her because she was still infatuated with another guy who was only interested in sex. The responses—mostly from women—largely supported her decision. More than a few posters argued that her boyfriend was not entitled to anything from her: “You don’t owe him anything.”

This has become a reflexive comment we use to shield ourselves from any sense of responsibility to other people. And it is nearly always wrong. We don’t owe every person everything, but we owe them something. It might be acknowledging someone’s perspective, giving someone our full attention, or offering respect. Perhaps it’s much more than that. We show each other kindness, respect, and decency not because people are worthy of these expressions, but because we are capable of providing them. A culture of obligation is built piece by piece, with small gestures, simple acts of compassion, and a consistent regard for others.

We live in a culture that no longer celebrates relational accomplishments. Being in a healthy marriage is an accomplishment. Being an active parent and raising kids who can be constructive and kind is praiseworthy. Our romantic relationships have become transactional rather than transformational. Admitting that we owe something to one another doesn’t require grand gestures or sweeping sacrifices, but rather a recognition that none of us can make it on our own.

“A culture of obligation is built piece by piece, with small gestures, simple acts of compassion, and a consistent regard for others.”

My wife and I will often get up a bit earlier than our kids, at least on school days. After making her tea in the morning, we’ll sit together in our living room. Sometimes we sit in silence as we take on the requisite amount of caffeine and prepare for the day. Most days, we’ll have our phones out, or occasionally a laptop. When we talk to each other, we do so through the dense attention fog these technologies produce. As a result, I do not always listen as closely as I should, sense the tenseness in her question as she wrestles with a challenging work problem, or remember all the details of our conversation a few hours later.

One morning, I decided to put the distractions away. She asked me a question, and I looked her in the eyes, thought for a minute about what she was asking, and replied. I don’t know whether it made any difference to her, but it made a difference to me.

Enjoy our full library of Book Bites—read by the authors!—in the Next Big Idea App:

Download
the Next Big Idea App

Also in Magazine

Sign up for newsletter, and more.